| | | | |

The $45 Poop Bag Holder That Never Rips Again (Even With My 70-lb Puller)

Byaloef9898

petguideclub.com – 2,212 words

I used to go through a leash-mounted poop bag holder every 2–3 months. My 70-lb dog pulls like a freight train, and every cheap plastic dispenser would crack, split, or just launch bags into the street the second he lunged. I was wasting money and picking up exploding bags in front of neighbors. Then I bought the #1 best-selling heavy-duty poop bag holder on Amazon that everyone said “actually survives big dogs.” Ten months later it’s still 100% intact, and I never run out of bags mid-walk again.

The Holder That Finally Beat My Dog: Earth Rated Leash Dispenser + 900-Count Bag Refill Pack

Current Amazon price (Dec 8, 2025 – Midwest Prime): Dispenser + 900 unscented bags → $44.99 (often $39.99 with coupon) → Find here on Amazon

Bought it after it held the #1 spot in Dog Poop Bags for 40 straight months with 150,000+ reviews averaging 4.8 stars. It is now permanently clipped to every leash I own.

Real features that survive real dogs:

  • Durable rubber strap + metal carabiner (not plastic)
  • Holds 1 full roll (15 bags) + extra roll inside
  • Patented hook that holds used bags until the trash
  • 900-count refill pack included (60 rolls)
  • Thick, leak-proof bags (unscented version)
  • 100% guaranteed not to tear

My 10-month apocalypse-proof log:

  • Day 1: First walk – he lunged at a squirrel. Dispenser didn’t move.
  • Week 2: Dropped it on concrete – zero cracks.
  • Month 3: Used the hook for 4 tied bags on a 3-mile walk – held perfectly.
  • Month 6: Accidentally left it outside in rain for 2 days – still perfect.
  • Month 10 (now): Just finished roll #48. Dispenser still looks brand new.

Cons:

  • Slightly bulkier than $9 plastic ones (but worth it)
  • Carabiner is loud if you’re stealth-walking

The Holders That Exploded on Me

  • #1: Earth Rated Dispenser + 900 Bags – $45 – Rubber strap + metal hook – 4.8★ / 150k+ → Find here on Amazon
  • #2: Gorilla Grip Dispenser – $8 – Plastic clip – Broke week 3 – 4.5★ / 80k → Find here on Amazon
  • #3: Amazon Basics Holder – $19 – Cheap plastic – Cracked month 1 – 4.3★ / 60k → Find here on Amazon
  • #4: Some $9 clip-on – $9 – Launched bags at full sprint – 3.8★ / 30k → Avoid
  • #5: Fabric pouch style – $15 – Ripped first tug – 3.9★ / 25k → Avoid

Final Verdict

If you have a big dog that pulls and you’re tired of broken dispensers and exploding bags: Buy the Earth Rated dispenser + 900-bag pack right now → Find here on Amazon

$45. Ten months. Zero failures. My walks are finally drama-free.

Disclosure: This site contains affiliate links. If you buy through one, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. All opinions are 100% my own.

Similar Posts